Pizza Pit - Lake Mills Menu (Update 2025)
Introducing the Menu of Pizza Pit - Lake Mills
Nestled in Lake Mills, WI, Pizza Pit boasts an extensive and mouthwatering menu that caters to pizza lovers and casual diners alike. Their specialty pizzas are a standout, featuring unique creations like the BBQ Bacon Chicken Pizza, Deluxe Combo, and the indulgent Mac-N-Cheese Pizza. Each dish is crafted with generous toppings and fresh ingredients that will leave you craving more.
Their Pizza Twins offer great value, perfect for sharing, while additional classic pizza options and delectable sides like wings and garlic bread elevate the dining experience. Reviews from satisfied customers highlight the inviting atmosphere, friendly staff, and consistent quality. With rave mentions of both dine-in and delivery services, it’s clear that Pizza Pit - Lake Mills stands as a must-visit spot for anyone seeking delicious pizza and a warm dining experience.
Classic Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Additional Toppings
Extra Sauce
2- Medium 12" Cheese. Pizzas
2- Large 14" Cheese Pizzas
2- Extra Large 16" Cheese Pizzas
Pizza Twins
Specialty Pizzas
Deluxe Combo Pizza
Pepperoni, sausage,fresh mushrooms, onions, green peppers
Super Meat Sampler Pizza
Pepperoni, canadian bacon, sausage,bacon, extra mozarella
Meatball Lovers
Extra sauce, meatballs, onions, green pepeprs, extra cheese
Garden Party Pizza
Fresh mushrooms, onions, black olives, green olives, tomatoes, green peppers
Bacon Onion Cheeseburger Pizza
Double bacon, beef onions, cheddar
Pepperoni Lovers Pizza
Double pepperoni,garlic, extra mozzarella
Sausage Mushroom Melt Pizza
Double sausage, fresh mushrooms, double cheddar cheese
Hawaiian Combo Pizza
Canadian bacon, pineapple, onions, green peppers, extra mozarella
BBQ Bacon Chicken Pizza
Sauced with Sweet baby ray's BBQ sauce, chicken, bacon, onions, tomatoes
Chicken Quesadilla Pizza
Sauced with spicy nacho cheese, chicken, bacon, onions, green peppers, black olives
Chicken Alfredo Pizza
Alfredo sauce, chicken, onions, fresh mushrooms, cheddar cheese
Mac-N-Cheese Pizza
Alfredo sauce, macaroni noodles and 2x cheddar
Beef
Italian Sausage
Salami
Pepperoni
Meatballs
Chicken
Bacon
Canadian Bacon
Mushrooms
Fresh Mushrooms
Green Olives
Black Olives
Onions
Garlic
Tomato
Pineapple
Green Peppers
Jalapenos
Banana Peppers
Extra Mozarella
Cheddar Cheese
Macaroni Noodles
Toppings
Pit Stix
12" Pit Stix
2 dipping sauces
14" Pit Stix
3 dipping sauces
16" Pit Stix
4 dipping sauces
Athens Gyro
Tender slices of our select, hand-carved lamb and beef, broiled on a vertical skewer with imported mediterranean spices and piled onto warm pita bred, smothered with onions, tomatoes and special homemade tzatziki sauce.
Gyros Plate
More of our gyro meat, plus French Fries.
Extra Pita
Extra Cucumber Sauce
Chicken Gyro
Tender slices chicken piled onto a warm pita bread, smothered with onions, tomatoes, and our homemade tzatziki sauce.
Chicken Gyro Plate
More of our chicken gyro plus French Fries.
Athens Gyros
Chicken and Fish
Chicken Wings
Meaty chicken wings with your dipping sauce
Just Drummies
Meaty chicken drummies with your dipping sauce
Tender Chicken Strips
Large chicken breast fillets with your dipping sauce
Chicken Strip Dinner
4 chicken strips with dipping sauce includes coleslaw & your chpise french fries, curly fries or potato salad
Fish & Shrimp Dinner
includes coleslaw & your your choice french fries, curly fires or potato salad
Boneless Chicken Wings
1 pound of our breaded boneless wings. Comes with 1 dipper sauce.
Classic Combo W/ Cheese
Layers of salami, pepperoni & canadian bacon
Meatball With Cheese
Beefy meatballs simmered in our pizza sauce, topped with green pepperes, onian and cheese
Turkey, Bacon, And Cheddar
Turkey, Bacon, and cheddar cheese.
Veggie Sub
Mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives, tomatoes
Ham & Cheese
Canadian Bacon topped with cheese
SUBS
Side Orders
Garlic Bread
Italian bread topped with buttery garlic spread
Cheese Bread
Garlic Bread topped with mozarella cheese
Breadstix
Bosco Sticks
Mozarella Sticks
Cheese Curds
Deep Fried Mushroom
Jalapeno Poppers
Onion Rings
French Fries
Homestyle French Fries
Curly Fries
Seasoned Curly Fries
6-Pack Warm Chocolate Chip Cookies
8" Warm Brownie
Pizza Cookie
Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream Pints
Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream Pints. Assorted Flavors.